I need Your WordPress Theme Recommendations

So, I will probably purchase a theme from Theme Forest for a new website and after spending hours looking at theme after theme with little understanding of what I am looking at or for, I sure can use some guidance from WordPress gurus regarding which themes may be most easily adapted to what I want to accomplish as well as what features I want to make sure my final choice includes.
The site will be a paid membership site where members can:

pay one low monthly fee and…

I need Your WordPress Theme Recommendations

See original post by Garyjay